The Smart Home Tech We’ve Added, Ditched, And Still Love Most

It has been almost 4 years since we last detailed the ways we use smart home technology to make our household more efficient. Since then we’ve changed homes, states, and even our smart home systems. So today I thought I’d break down what we’ve added, what we’ve gotten rid of, and what still has a stranglehold on my nerdy tech-loving heart (and even one that was Sherry’s idea!).

As usual, none of the products mentioned in this post are sponsored or gifted. It’s just stuff that we have bought and loved – or (in some cases) don’t love so much anymore. So let’s get into it.

STILL LOVE: Alexa Voice Assistant

Call us basic, but our Alexa voice-assistant devices are basically the couldn’t-live-without matriarch of our little smart home family. The Abuela to our Encanto. And, despite having downsized to a smaller home, we actually upsized the number of devices: going from 1 Amazon Echo and 2 Echo Dots in our last house to 2 Echos (for the upstairs and downstairs common areas) and 3 Dots (one for each bedroom).

Technically these weren’t new purchases (the extras had been in our beach house, which is why none of ours are the newer globe-shaped devices). But since Alexa is how we voice control many of our smart devices it’s been useful to have her available in more places around the home, particularly so the kids can use her in their rooms now too.

We also use them every single day to play music, set timers, ask for the weather forecast, create shopping lists, call the kids down for dinner, etc (it’s a lesser-known fact that Alexas are essentially a wireless whole-house intercom). Our kids also love asking Alexa for the temperature when they get dressed in the morning and requesting jokes or a story (or to play the Akinator game).

DITCHED: Alexa Auto

Since I’m fascinated with this stuff, I’m always intrigued by the random new Alexa-enabled products that Amazon announces. Eyeglasses! Rings! Analog clocks?! Well, I managed to resist those. But a couple of years ago I got on a half-price, early release list for the Echo Auto, a device that’s designed to work in your car through your phone. I even shared my excitement about it in this podcast episode.

But after a while, we got tired of how glitchy it was. Mostly it seemed to have difficulty hearing or understanding over any music playing, and responses were often slow and unhelpful. Maybe it has since improved or we just had a bad experience (it has 4 out of 5 stars on Amazon) but after about a year we decided it wasn’t worth having the bulky device and extra wires clogging our dashboard anymore, so we gave it away.

ADDED: Smart Blinds

Motorized roller shades are a new smart technology we tried in this house and they’re BY FAR our favorite new smart device. We love being able to control the blackout blinds that we added to each of our bedrooms with our voices (or use our phones to schedule regular routines). Since installing them nearly two years ago, Sherry has gotten so many questions about them that I’m planning to write a Smart Blind FAQ post that dives into them in much more detail – including how much they cost. Hoping to get that up in the next week or so.

The short version is that we ended up with these Bali Blackout Roller Shades with the smart motorization feature, in the Acadia Vintage Veil fabric. Sherry was skeptical about splurging for them, but since we only needed five of them total, she indulged me. And well, now she’s a loud and proud convert. It’s so nice to have the whole house go into night mode or morning mode with a simple command instead of walking into every room and flipping on or off lights and lowering or raising blinds. We’ve impressed more than a few friends by saying “Alexa, It’s bedtime,” and watching their eyes get wide as all of our lights lower and the bedroom shades all go down in unison.

STILL LOVE: Kasa Smart Light Switches, Bulbs, & Plugs

As smitten as I am with our smart blinds, my most trusted sidekicks will always be my collection of smart light bulbs, light switches, and plugs. We’ve been using the Kasa system for years and still have no complaints. We primarily use them to control various lights (for example: smart switches for overhead lights, smart bulbs for lamps, and smart outlets for things like table fans, salt lamps, and Christmas decor). We even use an outdoor smart plug to control our string lights.

I find all of the devices easy to set up, except for maybe the switches since they require some electrical skill to hardwire. But even those are pretty basic if you follow the step-by-step instructions. We also like that through Alexa we can control them with our voices (individually, in groups, or as part of routines – like that “Alexa, it’s bedtime” command mentioned above). We can also set fixed schedules, like our front porch light that turns on, off, and even dims according to that day’s sunrise and sunset. I could go on, but I won’t. They’re just the best.

How To Install A Smart Plug

Want to see a step-by-step rundown of how to connect a smart plug? We filmed this video a few years ago but the process has stayed the same. It really is a super simple thing to add to make your house more auto-pilot.

You can also watch this video on YouTube.

DITCHED: Flo Smart Water Monitoring

I’m not sure we’ve ever talked about our experience with the Flo by Moen devices we had at our beach house and duplex. We had them professionally installed on all three main water lines because they’re designed to detect unusual water usage (aka: leaks) and to shut off your house’s water to minimize flood damage if they detect a sudden gush. It wasn’t a cheap endeavor – the three devices alone cost nearly $1400 at the time – but seemed worth it to have peace of mind since we lived 2.5 hours away from these houses. They also allowed us to easily turn off the water from our phones if the homes were going to be unoccupied for an extended time or the area had a freeze warning.

However in our experience they caused more headaches than they prevented. It was partly due to the poor internet service there, which made controlling our Flo systems from the app very unreliable. We also received a faulty device at first that caused a brief but frustrating leak in our crawl space.

Most of all, we found the smart monitoring features incompatible with vacation homes that were occupied inconsistently and therefore never had “routine” water usage. You see, during our summer rental season, the app frequently sent us urgent alerts about “extended water use” (which were just families showering off after a day at the beach) and threatened to turn off the water if we didn’t clear the alert within a few minutes. Had I not been near my phone on these occasions, this could’ve left our renters waterless, sandy, and upset.

The only reason those alarms were triggered were because it was “more water usage than a few months before” – but you can see how winter months in a seasonal place would equate to fewer people using the house/water, so it just wasn’t a good method. After consulting their support we were never able to find a way to solve these false alarms and eventually had the devices completely deactivated. Perhaps their technology or interface has improved since 2019, but I can’t say we miss having them.

ADDED: “The Frame” Smart TV

Even though I don’t really think of our Samsung Frame TV as “smart home” technology (although it does have a built-in Alexa, I guess) I couldn’t leave it off this list. It’s been nearly 6 years since we cut the cable cord so using smart TVs for streaming isn’t new to us. But we jumped on The Frame TV  bandwagon when we moved here two years ago because we loved the promise of a smart TV that might look more like framed art nearly (it wasn’t cheap – but we just needed one). Here’s what we love about it:

• It’s super low-profile and hugs tightly to the wall, just like a picture frame.
• It has only one small wire, which connects to a control box (our box is hidden on the floor) where you can plug in your power and other components. Note: you can hide the wire in the wall using this method, we just haven’t yet.
• The custom bezels (we have the beige version) that snap magnetically to the edges really give the TV a picture frame appearance. Beige is a weird name, but it looks just like a blonde wood frame.

As we mentioned in our original take on it, we mostly have beef with the process to upload your own photo (it’s much more complicated than it would be if they supplied more clear instructions). We love that we can display a photo or artwork on the screen when it’s dormant – they have a library to choose from or you can upload your own like we did. You can also adjust the brightness and the warmth to make it look more convincing. Just don’t expect it to fool everyone into thinking it’s not a digital screen. It still looks way better than a big black box though. And honestly, we’d do it all over again just for the features bulleted above alone.

TIP: If you’re uploading your own photos to the Frame TV, first resize them to 3814 pixels wide by 2145 pixels tall. This will match the aspect ratio of the TV, which will make any mats you choose look even on all sides for the most art-like result.

STILL LOVE: Nest Learning Thermostat

I realized recently that this home marks the NINTH Nest thermostat we’ve installed (after 2 in our last home, 2 in our beach house, and 4 in the duplex). Clearly, we’re fans. While we do appreciate the ability to control it with our voices (“Alexa, turn downstairs up one degree”) our favorite features are its auto-away & auto-scheduling.

• Auto-away uses motion detection to determine when no one’s home and automatically sets itself to eco-mode, meaning it conserves use whether we’re gone for an hour or a whole week.
• Its learning capabilities use a variety of factors – seasons, motion detection, manual adjustments, etc – to automatically create a schedule for you. So it figures out when you typically wake up or head off to work and adjusts accordingly (you can always manually edit it too).

We chose the Learning Thermostat with the white outer band, but it also comes in black, brass, copper, and stainless steel. There’s also a more affordable non-learning version for $99. It can still be voice-controlled, it just doesn’t have the smart auto-schedule feature mentioned above. Just be sure to use this online compatibility test to ensure that your system works with either version before purchasing.

DITCHED: Racchio Smart Sprinkler Controller

This particular device got ditched NOT being we didn’t like it, we just don’t have an irrigation system in our new house so there was no need for it. Actually, we’re still big fans of the Racchio Smart Sprinkler Controller and I’ve even encouraged a few friends who have grass here to switch their system to it because it saves money and water. What’s not to love?

It allows you to control your sprinklers with your voice, but we never used it for that. Our favorite features were:

1. The ability to use a phone app to easily control and schedule our sprinkler system
2. The fact that the app uses local weather forecasts to determine if it should skip a scheduled watering, meaning there’s no need to install a separate rain sensor.

I can’t be the only person who finds it maddening to see a sprinkler system running furiously during a rainstorm. With the Smart Controller, you don’t have to be that person anymore.

ADDED: Pura Smart Fragrance

Here it is: the smart device that Sherry initiated purchasing! It’s the Pura Smart Diffuser. It’s like the techy, non-toxic version of those old-school Glade Plug-Ins (or does anyone else remember Febreeze Scentstories?? My roommate and I actually owned one after college). The whole natural and pet/kid safe slant was what sucked Sherry in, and you just plug the Pura into an outlet and insert two scent vials of your choosing. Then, using their app, you can toggle between the two scents, control their intensity, set schedules, and more.

I would say we’re both “fragrance sensitive” and find a lot of perfumes, cleaners, and essential oils way too overpowering. So it was nice to be able to crank our Pura down to a level 1 (out of 10, ha!) for just the right amount of fragrance for our delicate little noses.

I think the main reason these work so well is how much control you have over their intensity and the ability to set an auto-schedule so we are never overwhelmed by scent and it just subtly works in the background on its own.

Right now Sherry just has two schedules running back to back, so our Pura switches between the scent of Sherry’s favorite Anthropologie candle, which runs at a super low intensity from 8am to 1pm. Then from 1pm to 9pm it clicks over to this Signature Citrus scent, also running at a 1 out of 10 intensity. They’ve got TONS of scents to choose from, including many recognizable brands like Kenneth Cole, Thymes, Votivo, and more.

Truly the best features are that you can: 1) turn off the light on it (which we did immediately), 2) turn the scent up or down (so it’s never too much), and 3) set as many schedules as you’d like. Feels very very controllable and never too strong or bright thanks to those customizations.

STILL LOVE: HP Smart Printer

I know it’s weird to see the words “love” and “printer” so close to each other, but I still have no complaints about our HP Envy wireless printer and our HP Instant Ink subscription (our current printer model is no longer sold, but I linked the closest version available now). The printer itself has worked great for us and I’ve never had an easier time printing from multiple devices – including my phone! – than I have working through the HP Smart app. I waxed poetic on our podcast about how often I use the app’s ability to scan documents using my iPhone’s camera, and I even made a video of the process!

If you have trouble viewing the video above, you can watch it here on YouTube.

The HP Instant Ink subscription program was a lifesaver during all of those months of virtual learning at home. Basically, the printer automatically detects when you’re getting low on ink and ships you new cartridges. The monthly fee covers everything – the ink cartridges, the shipping, and the magic sensor in the printer that sends a signal to HP to send your new ink before it runs out. The amount you spend each month depends on how many pages you’re printing (anywhere from $1/month for 10 pages up to $25/month for 700 pages) so you can really customize it to your printing needs.

The fee we pay seems cheaper than it was just to buy ink on our own, and it even covers shipping the empty cartridges back for them to recycle. We’ve had it for a few years now and we’ve never been caught without ink on hand. And we love that it’s one less thing we have to worry about and one less errand we have to run.

ADDED: Smart Outdoor Cameras

The home security system we added to this house is the first time we’ve incorporated exterior cameras, primarily to keep a better eye on our pool and our front porch. These days, most video doorbells and outdoor cameras from the major security providers – like SimpliSafe, Ring, Nest, etc – offer pretty sophisticated motion detection customization. When they detect motion. Where they detect it. They can even distinguish human motion from, say, some random wildlife running across your yard or a palm leaf flapping in the wind.

Having outdoor cameras has given us lots of peace of mind, and they were easy to set up (no wiring required). They connect via Wifi and are powered by rechargeable batteries. We even updated ours with solar panels so they recharge automatically, for free from the sun.

We don’t share our exact alarm system brand & products just because we’ve heard it’s smarter not to broadcast that to the internet (in case someone wants to target you for a specific attack), but most major security providers like SimpliSafe, Ring, Nest, etc have pretty good reviews and choices for you to look into with everything from motion detection and phone alerts to higher tech things like glass-break sensing alarms (which set off the system instantly at the sound of glass shattering, like if someone breaks a window or a glass door panel).

So to recap, here’s a list of all the devices we’re currently using in our home:

I know it looks like a lot, but as much as I geek out on this stuff, we do try to be pretty discerning about what actually improves our life at home, and what is unnecessary or more trouble than it’s worth. I may have had Febreeze ScentStories in my past, but I don’t see some fancy Alexa-enabled sunglasses in my future. I least, not yet…

*This post contains affiliate links*

More posts from Young House Love